TWG LVI: Silence Will Fall

[K-NiGhT]

While I do see points on Waddle Bro's suspicion of Mr. Tanooki Suit, I don't think they're very practical. Seeing as it is day one, there is not much at all to go on. Like he said, there wasn't much to say until other people started posting suspicions. I do agree that his first post does seem a little odd, since he has nothing new to add, but really what else was there to add at that point?

I think I'll wait until more things happen to make my decision. I'm working on a suspicion list right now so that'll probably be posted sometime tonight.

[FireArrow]

I'd lynch Mr. Tanooki Suit more because he's the most suspicious, unless someone has some leads on someone else?

[vermilionvermin]

FireArrow, why do you think Tanooki's more likely a human than a wolf?  Just because Waddle accused him of being a wolf doesn't make him any more likely to be a wolf.

[FireArrow]

FireArrow, why do you think Tanooki's more likely a human than a wolf?  Just because Waddle accused him of being a wolf doesn't make him any more likely to be a wolf.

Do you mean more likely a wolf than human?

I agree with Waddle bro's logic about him, though while I don't think it's enough to warrant a lynch, so far he's our best candidate for a day 1 lynch.

[vermilionvermin]

Yeah, I meant more wolf than human.

I still don't understand why the second quote is wolfy, or why the case for filler is stronger than what could easily be made against BDS or TZP.  Could you explain?

[FireArrow]

The second quote is actually what convinced me. Don't you think it's wolfish to avoid being the first to give an opinion, that being said, it's a bit hard to believe that a wolf would actually tell everyone s/he's doing that.

An idea for scrambling the votes - we could vote our selves the first time, as we would never want to later in the game anyways.

[Mr. Tanooki Suit]

So if I have nothing to say, I'm a wolf for being inactive, but if I say something so I'm active but I'm really not too concerned about anything, I'm a wolf?

Brilliant deduction, holmes!

[K-NiGhT]

I'm sorry, FireArrow, but I'm really not sure I understand your reasoning for voting for Mr. Tanooki Suit. It's kinda hard to give an opinion first thing on the first day. Also, I think that post was also kind of a way of asking BDS a question. That's just my observation, of course, but I just don't see how that's extremely suspicious.

[TheZeldaPianist275]

Yeah, TBH I don't really see the basis for an accusation against Mr. T.  If it were later in the game and he was still posting a lot of filler, yes, I could see why then, but now?

The person who sticks out to me as behaving strangely right now is actually K-NiGhT.  Usually he's inactive enough to be booted by the end of Night 2.  I'm not overwhelmingly suspicious at all, but right now I think he's more suspicious than Mr. T.

[FireArrow]

So if I have nothing to say, I'm a wolf for being inactive, but if I say something so I'm active but I'm really not too concerned about anything, I'm a wolf?

Brilliant deduction, holmes!

Saying things doesn't equal activity. Also, TZP, I'm not overly suspicious of Mr. T, similarly to how your suspicious of K-Knight. It's Waddle Bro that's a bit more certain.

[K-NiGhT]

Yeah, TBH I don't really see the basis for an accusation against Mr. T.  If it were later in the game and he was still posting a lot of filler, yes, I could see why then, but now?

The person who sticks out to me as behaving strangely right now is actually K-NiGhT.  Usually he's inactive enough to be booted by the end of Night 2.  I'm not overwhelmingly suspicious at all, but right now I think he's more suspicious than Mr. T.

I've decided that I actually wanted to be active this game. I actually have time to play, therefore I shall play.

[The_Subjective_Thought]

An idea for scrambling the votes - we could vote our selves the first time, as we would never want to later in the game anyways.

I think this is a great idea for the day 1 vote.

[vermilionvermin]

Loxo

It's mid-day 1 and nothing from Loxo.  Loxo is a potential wolf partner with everyone, especially given how little there is to go on and how nobody's talked about the most obvious lynch candidate.

[K-NiGhT]

Oh wow i completely forgot about him...

Loxo

[Mr. Tanooki Suit]

Wait, Loxo's here? Wow! Sadly he hasn't posted anything... I'll vote for him if and only if nothing better comes up. I'm normally against lynching inactives, but hey, it's better than nothing.

N2 or D2, I'll post a suspicions list (that is, if I'm still alive by then).