The NinSheetMusic Redesign Suggestion Thread: Site features

[Trasdegi]

Oh, I didn't know that. So 1 more game than wouldn't have a star and than we haven't to check.

I would rather not have this "star system" on the site. That would look tacky and probably confuse visitors. May be just in a thread somewhere on the forums?

Yeah, people would find it strange to have games with 20 sheets or more and no star, and games with just 1 sheet and a star because this only sheet is up to today's standards. So maybe only put stars for games with all scores done and up to the standards, and have somewhere on the forums a list of games which doesn't need any fixing, but have tracks missing

[mikey]

It's like putting a band aid over a cut until it heals

[Trasdegi]

I just thought: but for games like Pokemon SMD, who came out really recently, there shouldn't be any problem, but... I just checked and there's a formatting issue in one of them. Sad.

[mastersuperfan]

There were Undertale sheets on-site before the arrangement project update.

But those were accepted in the current submission system...? So why shouldn't they be up to standards?

[Olimar12345]

Remember Temmie Village?

[Trasdegi]

The URL is missing. I really don't know how this got trough the submission system without being noticed

[Olimar12345]

The URL is missing. I really don't know how this got trough the submission system without being noticed

No it isn't?

[Trasdegi]

Was speaking of this one. Got on site a year and a half ago.

[Maelstrom]

I would rather not have this "star system" on the site. That would look tacky and probably confuse visitors. May be just in a thread somewhere on the forums?

Kinda with Oli on this. It's not a marker normal people would notice, understand, or even care about. It'd be easier just to keep a list on the forums, as oli said

[Cobraroll]

An even simpler and more user-friendly solution: Mark the games where we have the full OST arranged. Don't consider the quality of the arrangements just yet, chances are many users wouldn't know enough about that to need it, but I think they'd be interested in seeing which games have the entire soundtrack on site.

[Maelstrom]

That's better, I guess

[mikey]

How about a little gold circle with the letters "QA" and on the top of the site sort of where the link to the forum is there's a legend that has gold star for complete game and medal for quality assured

[Latios212]

I really don't know how this got trough the submission system without being noticed

Mistakes happen. That's why we have this

[Trasdegi]

It's already in Yug's nsm audit, so I don't think it's worth posting it in the error thread

[Yug_Guy]

It's already in Yug's nsm audit, so I don't think it's worth posting it in the error thread

No, that's not how the audit should be thought of. Post the mistake in the error thread, and I'll worry about taking it off the spreadsheet.