TWG XXXVIII: Snakes on a Plane

[Mashi]

In the scenario that SocialFox actually isn't the Doctor, I don't think that the real Doctor should claim.  If SocialFox truly is the Doctor, we'll probably learn that by the end of next Night Phase.

[K-NiGhT]

SocialFox lies. I am The Please! Claim to mii!!!!!!!!!!

[Bird]

If you are actually the doctor, you must claim!

If SocialFox isn't the doctor, he's a wolf and we risk other specials claiming to him. It's unfortunate that he claimed, but we can at least make use of it. If nobody counterclaims him, we can have the Cool Guy and Seer meet up through him, by claiming to him privately.

[Yugi]

If you are actually the doctor, you must claim!

If SocialFox isn't the doctor, he's a wolf and we risk other specials claiming to him. It's unfortunate that he claimed, but we can at least make use of it. If nobody counterclaims him, we can have the Cool Guy and Seer meet up through him, by claiming to him privately.

I was actully trying to protect the real docter by being a mouthpeice, but I guess that didn't work.

[Bird]

Well.

Disregard my previous post then.

I believe that your intentions were good, SocialFox, but normally if somebody false claims a role, it's a wolf up to no good rather than a human trying to protect somebody. Not an unreasonable maneuver for your first game though!

[FSM-Reapr]

Safety on Mr.Saturn

I'll miss you Blueflower.

[Yugi]

I lurked a bit before the sign-ups

[vermilionvermin]

I'd like to hear more from

3. Bubbles7689
5. Mr. Saturn
8. Kman96
9. gzgregory
10. Wrydryn
11. Jub3r7
13. K-NiGhT
14. spitllama
16. Spyro

What do you think of Kman, FSM, and SocialFox?  I think those three have said enough for there to be discussion on them.

[Mr. Saturn]

Alright, I've got one of the poisons. Whom should I use it on, boing?

[Kman96]

IM SORREEEEE....

OMG so much has happened today, and ive been unable to post the whole time.

...so i read over the thread, and it seems to me that perhaps, since no one has yet claimed to be the doctor after socialfox claimed,  it could mean either one of two things:

1. they dont trust the idea of claiming their role, so they are staying secret, or
2.its possible that Blueflower was the doctor, and the snakes had a 1/12 chance of snaking (wolfing?) him... out of mere chance.

thats onky what ive observed, but until you took back your claim, foxy, you could have had the wolves going. so, good job on the plan, bad job for taking it back. now we're at square 1 again.

[Kman96]

Alright, I've got one of the poisons. Whom should I use it on, boing?

Ok, I F'ed up, I distributed items when I shouldn't have.  If you got one, forget I said anything, and I don't think me telling Cool Guy who got the mushroom would alter the game.  Sorry about all this, I'll try not to mess up anything else.

-_-

[Mr. Saturn]

Weeeelllllllllllllll excuuuuse me, princess!

[Mashi]

Kman96, blueflower999 couldn't be the Doctor, because he was Green.
And it's good that SocialFox proclaimed that he was false claiming.  After Bird's post stating that the Doctor should counterclaim if he were false claiming, we were at risk of having the ostensibly real Doctor claim and possibly be wolfed next Night Phase.

[Bubbles]

What do you think of Kman, FSM, and SocialFox?  I think those three have said enough for there to be discussion on them.

Honestly I have no idea . Fsm always talks alot, so theres not much information there (I still luv you though fsm). Social is new, and I dont think I understand his strategy. Again, Kman said the thing about lying, and thats pretty suspicious, but I cant see any good outcome of revealing to everyone in the game that you're going to lie.

[Kman96]

Kman96, blueflower999 couldn't be the Doctor, because he was Green.

Oh. WOOOOOW.

Way to miss the details, Kman... 
My bad...

Again, Kman said the thing about lying, and thats pretty suspicious, but I cant see any good outcome of revealing to everyone in the game that you're going to lie.

Like I said, I screwed up. If you look at my playing style in other human games of mine, I always say that I'm a human and I never tell a lie. (now that I think of it, every time I was a wolf, I never said such a thing) I decided to change that plan a little late into the game, just in case anyone would hold me to the promise I made in other human games, but I guess no one remembered, so...yeah, I F'd up.