TWG XXVI: Doctor Who

[Dude]

Any of Jub's choices seem pretty reasonable... Except Slow cuz he's already been seen so that wouldn't make any sense.

[SuperFireKirby]

I'd go with blueflower, personally. He did just cap off the insta.

[Greg]

I honestly get the feeling he did it by accident.

I was thinking Dude, because we have approximately zero information about him.

[SlowPokemon]

Just thinking out loud, don't take this too seriously. Wrydryn both times essentially "capped off" (to use SFK's term) the insta--the first time actually causing the insta, the second leaving it so that if anyone hapless enough (or someone in on the setup) would vote for Davy, an insta was immediate. I mean, I also contributed to both, but I'm just saying. I'm guessing that Blueflower just didn't count the votes, and saw the points people were employing against Davy.

Also, Jub, don't act so innocent. You saw the insta before it happened and still kept your vote, right? Yah.

And Dude has been steering clear of the game, a tactic he often employs while a wolf. Of course, that's also just his style of playing, but we can't forget about him in the process of considering suspects. Similar situation for SuperFireKirby

Unless something happens after night, my main suspicions at this point are JUB3R7, SUPERFIREKIRBY, DUDE, and BLUEFLOWER. JUB3R7 is my main suspicion though, as well as BLUEFLOWER: for reasons stated below.

NOW FOR ANALYSIS:

IF WE ASSUME DAVY IS A WOLF:
Then let us assume that the wolf/wolves would not have voted for Davy. Of the eight other players, five voted for him. Let's look at who did not.
1. xK-NiGhTx - Seer.
2. gzgregory - he seems like a pretty convincing human from what I've seen in chat, but anything's possible.
3. Dude - He has been awfully low-key. Assuming that Davy is a wolf means I assume Dude is a wolf, and so was Mashi, as greg and KN are fairly convincing to me at this point.

IF WE ASSUME DAVY IS NOT A WOLF:
Then let us assume that the wolf/wolves would have voted for Davy. Of the eight other players, three people did not vote for him. Let's look at who did.
1. Jub3r7 - the one who started the voting. If I assume Davy is not a wolf, I must assume Jub3r7 is a wolf. His involvement in the game just strikes me as more than an inquisitive human at this point.
2. SuperFireKirby - the next voter. He's been playing low-key like I said earlier and comes in to vote for Blueflower based either on Jub's vote or on his own reasoning.
3. SlowPokemon - I don't like analyzing myself
4. Wrydryn - votes for Davy based on chat logs and his strange comments to Jub
5. Blueflower - basically says he knows that Davy might have a reason for hypocrisy (which I must have missed the evidence for anyway), but he doesn't want to give him a chance to explain himself. Either it's his inexperience, or he's a wolf.

[Dude]

3. Dude - He has been awfully low-key. Assuming that Davy is a wolf means I assume Dude is a wolf, and so was Mashi, as greg and KN are fairly convincing to me at this point.

I don't see where you're getting that from, but whatevs.

But anyway, Wry, SFK, and Slow are my top three choices. I don't know where everyone goes yet, but I'll get to that when the time comes.

[Dude]

And Dude has been steering clear of the game, a tactic he often employs while a wolf. Of course, that's also just his style of playing, but we can't forget about him in the process of considering suspects.

Didn't see this. It's because if I get into the game too much, it makes me want to punch babies/forum members.

[Wrydryn]

Seems like this insta was more of an accident than anything. I really think that in order to help ourselves we should be counting the votes when we make a vote like I did earlier.
For example:
player 1 votes for player 3 with "I vote for Player 3."
player 2 votes for player 3 with "Voting for Player 3; 2 votes now against them."


Remember to read the logs too, even if you skim them they let you make an informed vote.


Dude: You have been terribly inactive, not saying anything can be just as bad as saying something incriminating. You also tend to play like this when you have a role as a wolf as well. I did see you pop into the irc for a moment when everyone had left so you're still making an effort.
You're also being very dismissive about that accusation, leading me to think that you are a possible wolf.
Please do get into the game, even if it's irc mainly, we can talk to you. But it makes the game harder when you avoid it but signed up to be active in it anyways.

[SlowPokemon]

I don't see where you're getting that from, but whatevs.

But anyway, Wry, SFK, and Slow are my top three choices. I don't know where everyone goes yet, but I'll get to that when the time comes.

Basically I was doing a lot of assuming. I was assuming that any wolves would not have voted for him, and I don't really suspect greg or KN. So that would mean you were the other wolf, and mashi was the third.

[Dude]

You're also being very dismissive about that accusation

This is what happens when I post! Every time I do, it sounds "dismissive" or "suspicious" or some other words that I can't think of right now! That's why I'm usually inactive-ish TWG forum-wise! I'd prefer the chatroom to this any day! If you look back at every TWG game that I was lynched, this same thing happens over and over again!

...See? I used too many "!"s which means I'm annoyed now.

[Dude]

this same shit happens over and over again!

Fixed for emphasis.

[K-NiGhT]

This is what happens when I post! Every time I do, it sounds "dismissive" or "suspicious" or some other words that I can't think of right now! That's why I'm usually inactive-ish TWG forum-wise! I'd prefer the chatroom to this any day! If you look back at every TWG game that I was lynched, this same thing happens over and over again!

...See? I used too many "!"s which means I'm annoyed now.

Hmm...sounds suspicious...

totally kidding...don't hurt meh

[Wrydryn]

I don't see where you're getting that from, but whatevs.

That's what I mean, you're not even defending yourself. I'd rather have you say something and who knows, maybe if you're accused of being suspicious rather than inactive someone will come to your rescue.


For life after TWG I think you should learn to become a wordsmith.

[K-NiGhT]

What's a wordsmith?

[Dude]

You're not even defending yourself.

I shouldn't have to. I'm human.

For life after TWG I think you should learn to become a wordsmith.

But I hate English. ._.

What's a wordsmith?

I googled it, it's someone good with words.

[Wrydryn]

I shouldn't have to. I'm human.

If it were that way though the humans would be winning every game.



For future reference for you guys. If someone uses a word with -smith at the end, it usually means they're a master/skilled at that.