TWG XXVI: Doctor Who

[SuperFireKirby]

Was wondering about seering results myself.

I agree with Whirr the gzgreg should probably be removed. It could be inactivity, simple as that. But inactive players always pose a threat, since you can never really analyze them well enough to where you can be firm one way or the other, regarding their role, and a the while the can pick off players at night. It's happened several times.

Got ninja'd by greg,(and others). I don't think disregarding the insta'ing is the correct choice, though I do believe it has, for the most part, been firmly analyzed. Results: Inconclusive. But it should not be the ONLY thing analyzed, that is for sure. That is why I believe we should all head to chat to expose the liars!

In case Shado ends the day sooner than later(since he doesn't feel like giving us specific times) I think I'm going to have to vote for Slow.

[SlowPokemon]

Safety on blueflower I guess.

Also we should remember that Mashi's ploy could easily have been an attempt to get silly wolves to claim to him. All in all it's more likely a human thing to do than a wolfy thing.

Umm, what? No. Mashi doesn't think any of us are THAT stupid. I don't see how any human who wasn't just being stupid would say that.

[SlowPokemon]

I have no idea when day is ending and I don't really want to die so with that I change my vote to gzgregory. That was a weird comment and you already have a vote on you.

[Greg]

Take the new players for instance.

Anyways I'm going to vote for you,SP, because you supported an insta a bit more covertly than Wry did and honestly, at this point I think Mashi was human.

[Jub3r7]

gzgregory's busy being a public seer in another game, give him a chance, please.

[Wrydryn]

Quick log from IRC with SFK, myself, and Gzgreg

Seems like SlowPokemon is the best choice now.


(8:49:02 PM) gzgregory [~chatzilla@shacops-BFD83907.vc.shawcable.net] entered the room.
(8:49:34 PM) gzgregory: Hi I'm going to stop being inactive now. ><
(8:54:57 PM) [Wrydryn]: Heya
(8:55:07 PM) gzgregory: Okay, so...
(8:55:10 PM) [Wrydryn]: I'll call everyone in here hold o
(8:55:11 PM) [Wrydryn]: on*
(8:55:18 PM) gzgregory: Right then
(8:57:10 PM) [Wrydryn]: Alright, just posted
(8:57:45 PM) [Wrydryn]: So, as you were going to say?
(8:58:01 PM) Vera [Mibbit@shacops-8C77BED7.dyn.optonline.net] entered the room.
(8:58:57 PM) [Wrydryn]: Hi Mashi
(8:59:06 PM) gzgregory: I was going to sy
(8:59:08 PM) gzgregory: *say
(8:59:15 PM) gzgregory: Why do you think Mashi said Verm
(8:59:18 PM) Vera: im ded kant tawc!!!!!!!!!
(9:00:13 PM) SuperFireKirby [~SuperFire@FE82D388.41E1A7A5.32812BCC.IP] entered the room.
(9:00:22 PM) SuperFireKirby: ohai peoples
(9:00:23 PM) gzgregory: Talking to wry ok mashi
(9:00:27 PM) gzgregory: sup sfk
(9:00:33 PM) SuperFireKirby: wutup
(9:01:10 PM) SuperFireKirby: so gz, why the vote on blueflower?
(9:01:12 PM) [Wrydryn]: Hi there
(9:01:47 PM) gzgregory: it's called a safety
(9:01:52 PM) gzgregory: Anyways
(9:01:57 PM) gzgregory: I'm kinda unsure right now
(9:02:06 PM) gzgregory: because honestly
(9:02:14 PM) gzgregory: people who instad mashi were probably scared of him
(9:02:25 PM) gzgregory: cuz he's too pro for the rest of us
(9:02:29 PM) [Wrydryn]: I'd think so
(9:02:55 PM) [Wrydryn]: And it's also confusing to tell what is the truth and what are the lies with him
(9:03:10 PM) SuperFireKirby: o
(9:03:18 PM) SuperFireKirby: didn't see safety
(9:03:19 PM) gzgregory: Obviously you'd think so since you instad him
(9:03:22 PM) gzgregory:
(9:03:42 PM) [Wrydryn]: Well yah
(9:03:46 PM) [Wrydryn]: Because really
(9:04:06 PM) [Wrydryn]: With Mashi we're damned if we do lynch him and damned if we don't lynch him
(9:04:48 PM) SuperFireKirby: Rule #1 of TWG: Mashi, no matter the circumstance, is a wolf
(9:05:06 PM) [Wrydryn]: Well he was the wolf even when he was the host
(9:05:11 PM) [Wrydryn]: So yah
(9:05:16 PM) SuperFireKirby: EXACTLY
(9:06:21 PM) SuperFireKirby: Slow, to me, seems like a good candidate for wolf
(9:06:41 PM) [Wrydryn]: He does but also seems to be in a similar position to me
(9:06:51 PM) SuperFireKirby: true
(9:07:09 PM) gzgregory: You're less wolfy to me
(9:07:12 PM) SuperFireKirby: honaestly the whole thing was just a big mess
(9:07:13 PM) gzgregory: because honestly
(9:07:19 PM) gzgregory: a wolf wouldn't cause an insta directly
(9:07:21 PM) [Wrydryn]: It was a big mess
(9:07:27 PM) gzgregory: Not a skilled wolf anyway
(9:07:30 PM) gzgregory: which Wry presumably is
(9:07:45 PM) SuperFireKirby: wolves don't want to draw attention to themselves
(9:07:55 PM) [Wrydryn]: ^
(9:07:57 PM) SuperFireKirby: wry did a hell of a job at getting it
(9:08:02 PM) [Wrydryn]: Oh yes I did
(9:08:18 PM) [Wrydryn]: But what I want is the seer report
(9:08:20 PM) SuperFireKirby: that is the number one reason you're not at the top of my list
(9:08:25 PM) SuperFireKirby: because I expect from from you
(9:08:31 PM) [Wrydryn]: Well that's good to know
(9:08:40 PM) SuperFireKirby: but you and slow both are high
(9:08:42 PM) SuperFireKirby: davy too
(9:08:54 PM) SuperFireKirby: on the list, that is
(9:08:56 PM) [Wrydryn]: I would hope so though
(9:09:06 PM) [Wrydryn]: Because if I wasn't then the humans are damned
(9:09:28 PM) SuperFireKirby: but gz
(9:09:39 PM) gzgregory: ?
(9:09:40 PM) SuperFireKirby: you might want to make a definitive vote
(9:09:44 PM) gzgregory: I'll do that
(9:09:50 PM) gzgregory: When does phase end again?
(9:09:55 PM) SuperFireKirby: as who knows when sk will decide to end the day?
(9:10:08 PM) [Wrydryn]: I think he said 8-10
(9:10:14 PM) [Wrydryn]: Or was it 8-12?
(9:10:15 PM) gzgregory: Today?
(9:10:19 PM) [Wrydryn]: Yes today
(9:10:20 PM) SuperFireKirby: also, what's up with xK
(9:10:24 PM) [Wrydryn]: No idea
(9:10:33 PM) SuperFireKirby: he's active, yet he hasn't given us the seer results
(9:10:36 PM) gzgregory: I'd like to see a seering result before day ends honestly
(9:10:47 PM) gzgregory: this is just really shifty
(9:10:48 PM) [Wrydryn]: This leads me to two conclusions
(9:10:50 PM) gzgregory: eugh
(9:11:00 PM) SuperFireKirby: unless he missed putting in a pm
(9:11:05 PM) [Wrydryn]: Either the wolfs killed the real seer and he was a proxy
(9:11:18 PM) [Wrydryn]: Or he missed the pm
(9:11:31 PM) SuperFireKirby: the latter seems way more liekly
(9:11:37 PM) [Wrydryn]: Yah
(9:11:38 PM) gzgregory: I think the wolves would have picked a more skilled proxy, yes
(9:11:51 PM) [Wrydryn]: Hmm?
(9:11:57 PM) gzgregory: I think I'm going to throw a vote on SP
(9:12:59 PM) [Wrydryn]: Hmm...
(9:13:25 PM) [Wrydryn]: I think Slow would be a better choice to vote than you
(9:14:49 PM) SuperFireKirby: you might want to start being more active gz
(9:14:57 PM) [Wrydryn]: Oh, I also want to point out
(9:15:01 PM) SuperFireKirby: your a very good player and we'll nedd you to win this
(9:15:13 PM) [Wrydryn]: Kinda odd that the Manti rule isn't applying
(9:15:40 PM) [Wrydryn]: But I think I explained that in my previous post
(9:16:11 PM) gzgregory: Anyways
(9:16:16 PM) gzgregory: I have to go
(9:16:18 PM) gzgregory: Bye guys
(9:16:22 PM) [Wrydryn]: Bye
(9:16:27 PM) gzgregory: I hope we're not making the wrong decision here
(9:16:28 PM) [Wrydryn]: I'll post the log later
(9:16:30 PM) gzgregory left the room (quit: Q:- ChatZilla 0.9.88 [Firefox 9.0.1/20111220165912]).
(9:16:42 PM) [Wrydryn]: Welp
(9:17:06 PM) SuperFireKirby: jerk
(9:17:07 PM) SuperFireKirby: leaving us
(9:17:11 PM) [Wrydryn]:
(9:18:13 PM) [Wrydryn]: Looks like it's curtains for SP
(9:20:24 PM) SuperFireKirby: yep
(9:21:11 PM) [Wrydryn]: Alright, I'll post the log then

[K-NiGhT]

 I seer'd Slow...he's green. But this was before this day phase when ppl started claiming to me :0

[Greg]

Shadowkirby why are your day phases so short D:

Safety on Blueflower again. I'm going to rethink this.

[SlowPokemon]

Ouch. Four votes against me. Okay then.

Edit: ninja'd, down to three. I'm changing my vote to Jub as a half safety thing.

[K-NiGhT]

K now that i've had time to think...and since my last seeing didn't do anything...Jub3r7

[Jub3r7]

So slow is either a master wolf or no wolf at all; the latter might be more likely, but the former is still a possibility, too.

Also now there are two votes on me.


Listen, if I were a wolf, why would I have told you not to post the claims publicly with my reasoning as so the wolves won't be able to determine the guardian?

That's one thing, but slow placed a half-safety, and you usually don't bandwagon on a safety unless you're 100% sure the person is a wolf.
What's your reasoning for voting me rather than somebody else who doesn't have any votes yet? I'm human, you know.

[K-NiGhT]

Ugh i can't keep track of ppl claiming! So many messages D:

K i'm going to say...Wry.

Sorry. That's my FINAL answer.

[master_gamer38]

Note to shadowkirby:

Day phases need to be at least 48 hours. Sometimes people cannot get on in just one day to talk to others. You also need to give a specific time on when the phase is ending. If you do not give a time players do not know how long they can discuss and end up being rushed.

As a result of the two things listed above:

I am extending the phase.

Day Two now ends at 11:00 PM EST, on Wednesday, January 25th.

If this time inconveniences you, I will count the votes and update it myself.

[Greg]

I'm voting for Davy following the seering reveal.

[19:23:37]   gzgregory   Erm.
[19:39:08]   [Wrydryn]   gzgregory
[19:39:13]   gzgregory   yes?
[19:39:45]   [Wrydryn]   What do you think
[19:39:56]   gzgregory   I... really don't know
[19:39:57]   [Wrydryn]   Should we follow xk's lead?
[19:40:14]   [Wrydryn]   He is the seer so I feel like it would be best to follow his lead
[19:40:32]   gzgregory   Huh
[19:40:35]   gzgregory   Why jub, though?
[19:40:52]   gzgregory   He provided zero reasoning for that vote.
[19:40:57]   gzgregory   I'm not sure.
[19:41:17]   [Wrydryn]   Well Slow sure as heck isn't a wolf
[19:41:25]   gzgregory   Mhm
[19:41:26]   [Wrydryn]   And I'm pretty sure you aren't
[19:41:30]   gzgregory   Kewl
[19:41:37]   gzgregory   My next suspicion was davy
[19:41:54]   [Wrydryn]   Davy is iffy
[19:41:57]   gzgregory   He said he didn't want an insta
[19:42:01]   gzgregory   But then what does he do
[19:42:05]   gzgregory   Leaves the vote on
[19:42:15]   gzgregory   And I think his reasoning is kinda not great
[19:42:17]   [Wrydryn]   Actually that's a valid point
[19:42:35]   [Wrydryn]   But we're going to get a KiTB if us two vote for Davy
[19:43:10]   gzgregory   We're just going to have to convince more
[19:43:17]   [Wrydryn]   And I need to switch my vote soon to save Slow
[19:43:26]   gzgregory   Switch to davy for now
[19:43:30]   gzgregory   Provide this log as your reasoning
[19:43:33]   gzgregory   I'll do so as well
[19:43:37]   gzgregory   We'll see what happens
[19:43:58]   [Wrydryn]   Oh derp
[19:44:01]   [Wrydryn]   I completely forgot
[19:44:11]   [Wrydryn]   Slow could be the masterwolf
[19:44:51]   [Wrydryn]   Uhm
[19:45:02]   [Wrydryn]   Now I really don't know what to think
[19:45:10]   [Wrydryn]   
[19:45:18]   gzgregory   ><
[19:45:25]   gzgregory   I think davy's a better bet than Slow though
[19:45:47]   [Wrydryn]   But we a KiTB with Jub, Slow, and Davy then
[19:45:53]   gzgregory   Eugh
[19:46:00]   [Wrydryn]   we get a*
[19:46:36]   [Wrydryn]   Hmm
[19:49:53]   [Wrydryn]   Based on what we already said I think I'm going to have to stick with Slow being the masterwolf
[19:51:34]   gzgregory   Huh.
[19:51:44]   gzgregory   That's fairly risky.
[19:52:28]   [Wrydryn]   
[19:52:40]   [Wrydryn]   But I feel less convinced on everyone else
[19:53:19]   gzgregory   I think I'm still going to vote for davy
[19:54:37]   [Wrydryn]   It's a good idea but unless we can get one more vote for davy I'd rather stick to Slow
[19:54:48]   [Wrydryn]   I don't want to risk Jub being lynched
[19:57:40]   [Wrydryn]   Try to convince Jub to vote for Davy then I guess
[19:58:14]   [Wrydryn]   pokes gzgregory
[19:58:25]   gzgregory   Hmm okay

Jub, no need to vote for Davy anymore since phase got extended and you now have only one vote on you. But it's something to think about.

[K-NiGhT]

Augh u guys are confusing me with the claiming! Idk who's telling the truth. I gotta go with someone who didn't claim i guess...gzgregory

Now i'm done i think.