TWG XXIV: Sauce Is Pretty Coll

[davy]

Bird and I are in chat ATM, so if you like you can join

[Bird]

You seem very concerned with protecting Verm, so either you are POSITIVE he's a human (which you can never be sure of), or you're both wolves. Either way, I get the vibe from you.

If you guys quite accusing verm, I'll quit protecting him! But don't expect me to sit idly while somebody I think is human takes a lot of heat from the rest of you.

And of course I'm not positive he's human, but I'm pretty darn sure. And since this "verm and bird" are partners rumor keeps popping up, I might as well post these:

http://pastebin.com/1YNSw5Q9

I don't think any wolves are insane enough to fake that many hours of IM conversation!

[Bird]

[13:58:47]   -->|   spitllama (Mibbit@shacops-636970D9.bendbroadband.com) has joined #twg
[14:03:06]   |<--   davy has left irc.drshnaps.com (Q:- NSM Chatroom)
[14:09:20]   spitllama   Who are your suspicions Bird
[14:16:27]   <--|   spitllama has left #twg

18 minutes, come on, you can do better than that! I was in the shower!

Here are my suspicions in order from most likely to be a wolf to least likely to be a wolf.

1. spitllama
2. gzgregory
3. Jub3r7
4. davy
5. Locke (Faux)
6. vermilionvermin
7. SuperFireKirby
8. Bird

But this list is subject to change. I'm actually about to reread the thread.

[Bird]

Hey guys, what if Dude was the brutal human and blueflower999 was a wolf! How crazy would that be!

And I reread the thread and still can't decide between gzg and spitllama. I think this quote makes Jub3r7 seem more human though.

"if the hunter were to seer someone green or something, could it still be a wolf given that a wolf painted himself green during that same night phase?"

Unless its a super tricky move by the wolf-genius Jub3r7.

For now I'll stick with spitllama though, since he seems less likely to be a special than gzg.

[Bird]

d'oh

spitllama

[spitllama]

I am definitely not a wolf. Why would I try to be active in the first place? I went to your chat, you weren't there. So d'oh is quite right. I gave you answers to your questions on the last page, what now?

[Bird]

[15:27:05]   -->|   spitllama (Mibbit@shacops-636970D9.bendbroadband.com) has joined #twg
[15:28:17]   Mr_Bird   hi
[15:28:53]   davy   hi spit
[15:29:50]   Mr_Bird   is jubert a good wolf?
[15:31:01]   davy   I dont know if he's been a wolf already
[15:31:10]   davy   I've never played against him as wolf
[15:31:26]   Mr_Bird   alright well
[15:31:29]   Mr_Bird   earlier, he asked:
[15:31:39]   Mr_Bird   "if the hunter were to seer someone green or something, could it still be a wolf given that a wolf painted himself green during that same night phase?"
[15:31:48]   Mr_Bird   isn't that like... a really obvious question
[15:31:54]   Mr_Bird   the entire point of the painter is to mess up seer results
[15:32:13]   Mr_Bird   and i was wondering if it was an attempt to look humna
[15:32:14]   Mr_Bird   human*
[15:32:34]   davy   I don't think we have played with a painter that often
[15:32:40]   davy   so I can understeand
[15:43:46]   |<--   spitllama has left irc.drshnaps.com (Q:- http://www.mibbit.com ajax IRC Client)

 

[davy]

I don't have any idea who to vote.

So safety on davy

[Bird]

spitllama: If that last post wasn't clear, when you came back to the chat when davy and I were both active, you said nothing then left. Kinda suspect.

And even though you responded to my questions, you didn't respond to my response. I'm your top suspicion, you say? Still? Why? I already proved that Verm and I couldn't be wolves together. The only other explanation is that I'm a human trying to defend another player who I believe is human. (Or a wolf who is trying to look human by needlessly defending a human, which would be pretty counterproductive and unlikely.)

So who do you suspect now and why?

[Bird]

[16:04:24]   -->|   spitllama (Mibbit@shacops-636970D9.bendbroadband.com) has joined #twg
[16:04:44]   spitllama   You there
[16:04:56]   Mr_Bird   hi
[16:05:08]   Mr_Bird   why didn't you say anything last time!
[16:05:26]   spitllama   I left the computer. Sorry
[16:05:45]   spitllama   So, use your jedi mindtricks
[16:06:08]   spitllama   I intend to remove all suspicion of myself by answering your questions like the human I am
[16:06:41]   Mr_Bird   uh
[16:06:45]   Mr_Bird   okay
[16:06:48]   Mr_Bird   who are the wolves
[16:07:19]   spitllama   I think gzg is >.<
[16:07:40]   Mr_Bird   who else
[16:08:32]   spitllama   Hmm well either Locke is human or he's the traitor so not him, verm and yourself are one or the other as a pair
[16:08:41]   spitllama   I'm not sure about davy, he's kind of in and out
[16:09:19]   Mr_Bird   err... so you don't think dude was a wolf?
[16:09:53]   spitllama   Of course, but he's out so who cares
[16:11:27]   Mr_Bird   alright, i asked the question weirdly
[16:11:29]   Mr_Bird   let me rephrase
[16:11:43]   Mr_Bird   this game has two wolves who may be alive or dead: who are they (i just want two names!)
[16:12:13]   spitllama   Wait there are only two wolves? I thought it was 50/50
[16:12:59]   Mr_Bird   what do you mean 50/50
[16:13:28]   spitllama   Like half of the players are brutals and half of the players are human
[16:13:42]   Mr_Bird   um... not really
[16:13:50]   Mr_Bird   If you look at the first post in the game thread, you'll see a list of roles.
[16:13:58]   Mr_Bird   http://www.ninsheetm.us/smf/index.php?topic=4025.msg130460#msg130460
[16:14:13]   Mr_Bird   every person in the game gets one of those roles, so that all of the roles are taken by one of the players who signed up
[16:14:19]   Mr_Bird   that means that there will be two wolves
[16:14:29]   Mr_Bird   (who, when lynched, cause another player to die, since they're both brutal wolves)
[16:14:45]   Mr_Bird   and there's also a brutal human, who will cause a person to randomly die when they are lynched
[16:15:26]   spitllama   Ok. I see. Then I guess Dude and davy/gzg
[16:16:32]   Mr_Bird   What makes you think Dude was a wolf rather than the brutal human?
[16:18:58]   spitllama   Cause he posted a grand total of 2 things, and he's one of the most active of the regular users on ninsheet
[16:19:34]   Mr_Bird   You don't think he had real life activities preventing him from posting?
[16:19:57]   spitllama   No, because he was posting on the ninsheet main site >.<
[16:20:52]   Mr_Bird   Fair enough.
[16:20:54]   spitllama   Why what do you think
[16:20:57]   Mr_Bird   So why do you suspect Davy then>
[16:21:11]   spitllama   Just cause I don't know much about him
[16:21:21]   spitllama   I would probably apply a safety to him at most
[16:21:42]   Mr_Bird   okay, so you think that the most likely wolf pairing is gzg partnered with dude?
[16:22:52]   spitllama   Yes, because gzg is acting different than when he was a human in the past, and dude doesn't have any support for his case from previous posts, despite his activity on the site
[16:25:38]   spitllama   Now you Bird, who (besides me apparently) is the wolf?
[16:25:55]   Mr_Bird   um
[16:25:58]   Mr_Bird   well the problem is
[16:26:04]   Mr_Bird   i think gzg is the most suspicious person in the game right now
[16:26:05]   Mr_Bird   BUT
[16:26:12]   Mr_Bird   it's pretty unlikely that he'd be partnered with dude
[16:26:41]   Mr_Bird   because gzg voted for dude when dude had 3 votes on him
[16:27:16]   spitllama   What makes dude the wolf
[16:28:04]   Mr_Bird   well, it sort of makes me think that dude might not have been a wolf after all!
[16:29:00]   Mr_Bird   but that still leaves another wolf in this game
[16:29:07]   Mr_Bird   my guess would be locke if he isn't the traitor
[16:29:57]   Mr_Bird   ANYWAY
[16:30:02]   Mr_Bird   you've convinced me that you're not a wolf
[16:30:04]   Mr_Bird   so good job!

gzg

[spitllama]

Gzg for above reasons

[spitllama]

Oops. No editing sucks. Gzg

[Bird]

I'm like... 90% sure that gzg is a wolf now. I can make a really strong case for every player's humanity except for his. I'm not sure if Dude was his partner, or Blueflower999, but I feel like this game is just about wrapped up.

[Greg]

Well great.
Voting for davy, because of his safety on himself. The only person he's targeted this phase has been Bird. Once that fell through, he safetied, despite the fact that there are plenty of targets (namely me and spit, when he'd safetied). Also the other arguments that he's human could have been done by an experienced wolf.

[SuperFireKirby]

^either this is just an awful excuse to try and sneak the lynch onto Davy or...wait ti is. Dumb human or slightly less dumb wolf move. I'll go with the latter for now.

Gzgreg(not voting for him at this second to help prevent an insta)

Also, Bird has become less suspicious to me because he didn't insta Jub. But he could have easily been away from his computer the entire time that little mess was going on. Still high on my list.