TWG CXIX: Luigi Wins by Doing Absolutely Everything

[Oricorio]

Given what just happened, I think its fair to assume Waluigi is the Aloof Wolf. We'll see what davy says on the rules, but even if it's possible, it's extremely unlikely (as TZP pointed out).

That being said, Luigi (who we haven't heard from) is likely Aloof Seer.

Im trying to think if any drawbacks of Luigi sharing his seer result. I cant really think of any, besides potentially making a blue player a target for the next night.

But the town seer seers blue as green? Didn't someboday already make this mistake?

[Oricorio]

I'd like to think that both partners would talk things through before posting, especially when claiming to reveal seer results

Waluigi outed their "result" 11 minutes after start of phase, barely any time to discuss anything

[TheZeldaPianist275]

Well, the thing is the slip was going to be called out anyway, so why not call it out if you're a wolf so you get the jump on town? The slip was almost certainly not planned, but that doesn't mean the wolves can't do damage control

I already shared this with Math and Specs on the side—that was my initial thought, but BDS didn't reply until more than an hour and a half after the Waluigi seer claim. That's quite a long time to wait if he were a wolf just trying to bag easy human points. It's also very far from BDS' playstyle lol

[SpecsFlyer17]

But the town seer seers blue as green? Didn't someboday already make this mistake?

Yeah, I meant it more as "we could get someone important targeted as the result of a positive trusted seer result".

[BlackDragonSlayer]

Waluigi outed their "result" 11 minutes after start of phase, barely any time to discuss anything

That's assuming the wolves hadn't already discussed it the night before, which seems like the most logical thing to do. Pre-planning what they'd "reveal" as their results is the safest best. Revealing their actual results (especially if they seered a blue player) has a chance to backfire and help the humans.

[Oricorio]

That's assuming the wolves hadn't already discussed it the night before, which seems like the most logical thing to do. Pre-planning what they'd "reveal" as their results is the safest best. Revealing their actual results (especially if they seered a blue player) has a chance to backfire and help the humans.

They wouldn't have known the results until the beginning of the phase though. Outing the "blue" specificly was unlikely to have been planned.

[Oricorio]

The idea that two wolves would have discussed outing a blue result for hours and not realize the obvious problems is simply absurd to me. I'd like to think that we're all smarter than that.

[SpecsFlyer17]

The idea that two wolves would have discussed outing a blue result for hours and not realize the obvious problems is simply absurd to me. I'd like to think that we're all smarter than that.

Sure, but why would the Aloof Seer fake a seering result? That seems weird too.

Unless you're suggesting the Aloof Wolf purposely claimed an impossible seer result for another reason?

[Oricorio]

Sure, but why would the Aloof Seer fake a seering result? That seems weird too.

Unless you're suggesting the Aloof Wolf purposely claimed an impossible seer result for another reason?

Nah, I'm more saying that the wolves weren't thinking when outing the result and any attempts to figure out their "plan" will mislead us. I feel it was primarily the fault of one wolf who made the slip, and the other wolf likely had nothing to do with that.

[davy]

I think. Actually lets get a TWG Question ruling from davy. If the COs seering is changed to blue from a correct redirection, does it remain blue or change to green?

The seering will be changed to the blue player, who will be seered green by the alsof seer

[Toby]

LOL

Well I guess we don't need anyone to claim to find out the human aloof seer?

But bit odd to claim a blue seering ? Surely claim a red and stir the pot day 1

[Oricorio]

So yeah, it's impossible for town to have a blue result. Pretty big slip there.

[Oricorio]

I'm making a bet here, that Waluigi account isn't posting again.

[BlackDragonSlayer]

There's a chance Waluigi was just doing a reaction test to see who picked up on the fact that a blue seering is impossible, but I highly doubt that.

Interested to see what TWG Luigi has to say. They... certainly have a lot more credibility at this point

[SpecsFlyer17]

Yep, blue seering was impossible. Would like to hear from Luigi