TWG CXV: Just a Numbers Game

[TheZeldaPianist275]

warning liberals: do NOT say "PNS" out loud very quickly

[XiaoMigros]

Claiming PNS after someone else prevents the wolf from knowing his identity. This puts a roadblock on the wolf+PNS teaming up that we have discussed.

Ah I see. This certainly complicates things, but I'm glad we have the time to work through them...

[XiaoMigros]

warning liberals: do NOT say "PNS" out loud very quickly

joe biden??!! soada

[XiaoMigros]

This is a reasonable thing to say, but if I PMd you and said "stop talking about this publicly" wouldn't it have seemed odd to everyone else to just drop that topic of conversation suddenly? I responded kinda impulsively because I was at a wedding, and I suppose I could have said something to you privately, but I'm not wholeheartedly convinced that it would have been better.

Yeah this is where my thoughts lie too, PMing this seems to be overthinking things a little idk

[A# Minor]

warning liberals: do NOT say "PNS" out loud very quickly

honestly tho

[Toby]

This is a reasonable thing to say, but if I PMd you and said "stop talking about this publicly" wouldn't it have seemed odd to everyone else to just drop that topic of conversation suddenly? I responded kinda impulsively because I was at a wedding, and I suppose I could have said something to you privately, but I'm not wholeheartedly convinced that it would have been better.
I don't suspect you for being the PNS--I suspect you for being the wolf. And I didn't suspect you because you claimed PNS, I initially interpreted that as a smokescreen which I thought was fine. It was E. Gadd's backup message that made me lean that way.
At the time you also suggested that a counterclaim from you or me wouldn't carry much weight, since we had already spoken out against it in the thread. I asked Specs if he would do it instead, and he declined. Specs verify this please
It wouldn't need to be E. Gadd making that deduction lol--it could just as easily have been you, couldn't it? I'm not saying I know what happened behind the scenes with you two, I'm just saying that this post looks like you two have been communicating privately and coordinating a narrative.

Okay but I shared the PM's that THC said me here that shows he actually did believe I was PNS during Night 1. So he didn't just express it to me, he also expressed it to Egadd. Does that answer your suspicion with Egadds post

[XiaoMigros]

TZP, what do you think of wolf!E. Gadd and PNS!Toby? I think it's quite possible that A# Minor's initial PNS claim was just an attempt to bait the wolf, in my mind that fits their character.

[SpecsFlyer17]

At the time you also suggested that a counterclaim from you or me wouldn't carry much weight, since we had already spoken out against it in the thread. I asked Specs if he would do it instead, and he declined. Specs verify this please

This is correct. I declined because I had literally just denied being the PNS in the public thread. That would've looked super sus

[Toby]

These are my PMs from E.Gadd:

Question for you, what are your thoughts on A#? You haven't really said much about her counterclaim for the PNS.

Well, assuming you are the PNS, I definitely want to help you win before we get the wolf. Regardless of who it is, I'm wanting to not lynch the PNS to give them a win, too. May as well help everyone we can be victorious.

Have you had any communication with A# directly on the matter?

And finally, who do you find most suspicious at the current moment? I thought A#, but now I'm not so sure...

Good grief getting ninja'd 11x is not fun. Anyway, Xiao just made a pretty major post pointing at you and A#. I'm still not convinced fully that it's you or her, so in my mind, it could be Xiao assembling something? But at the same time, I don't see that as a desperate wolf since no one has overtly expressed suspicions of them. My worry is it's TZP or Magnet. But for now, I'm holding off on suspicion bc I have a meeting (I'm speedwalking as I type this) but I want to see you respond to Xiao's message.

Also apologies for misreading your most recent PM, reading is really hard :< I'm gonna fight to make sure accuracy is maintained if someone tries to run against you with that first misreading I made.

If you think he's trying to find the PNS maybe he is but it's not me and I've not been working with him to find it. I'm been holding my bluff that I was the PNS

I did also think Egadds suspicion list here where he found no one suspicious was odd

[SpecsFlyer17]

warning liberals: do NOT say "PNS" out loud very quickly

PNS destroys wolf with FACTS and LOGIC

[XiaoMigros]

E. Gadd sus

These are my PMs from E.Gadd:
If you think he's trying to find the PNS maybe he is but it's not me and I've not been working with him to find it. I'm been holding my bluff that I was the PNS

hot damn E. Gadd sus

[XiaoMigros]

why did it put it twice :sob:

[A# Minor]

why did it put it twice :sob:

You are very suspicious of him, which is reasonable. No need to sob XD

[XiaoMigros]

That's true. Speaking of which, provisionally, E. Gadd

[XiaoMigros]

Are you considering changing your vote, A#?