Kothund's Submissions

[SlowPokemon]

Also the pieces are exactly the same, there's no tempo difference that I can hear.

[TheZeldaPianist275]

Marioguy:

1) For one thing, the reason nobody has responded to your question is that this sounds INCREDIBLY trivial.  Both have miniscule differences that no one would notice.

2) It sounds pretty rude to say 'come on people' for something like this.  If you play piano AT ALL, you should be able to listen to the music and rhythms and spot the differences.  You're asking us to set aside our valuable time to do something you could easily do yourself, and for something that sounds petty.  Care to tell us why it's so important?

As long as I'm typing this up, though, I might as well....

I just listened to the song.  About 40 seconds in, two wind instruments start weaving around each other.  The differences in Kothund's sheet are actually both acceptable, because in one sheet in that measure, it shows one woodwind's part, but on the other sheet, it shows the other wind.  That make sense?  They're technically both correct.

[Brassman388]

Stop striving for perfection and accuracy and just write the dang piece.

As long as it sounds correct and it's playable, then there's no need for it to be perfect. That's the sole purpose of an arrangement, it's YOUR interpretation.

Just something to ponder, mate.

[SlowPokemon]

I agree completely. A playable arrangement that sounds correct is much better than an arrangement that is perfectly accurate, but difficult to the point of ridiculousness.

[marioguy]

Marioguy:

I just listened to the song.  About 40 seconds in, two wind instruments start weaving around each other.  The differences in Kothund's sheet are actually both acceptable, because in one sheet in that measure, it shows one woodwind's part, but on the other sheet, it shows the other wind.  That make sense?  They're technically both correct.

Thanks. I was justing wondering why he/she made two different versions of the same song and also which version was made first.

[TheZeldaPianist275]

Why was that so important?

[marioguy]

Why was that so important?

Because I don't want to use a version that's fundamentally wrong. The difference in measure 16 really bothers me for some reason. I've decided to go with the version from Majora's Mask and see how that goes.

[monkeybull223]

the link isn't working for me.  i tried on Explorer, Chrome and FireFox and i got a server error everytime.  is that happening to anybody else?

[marioguy]

the link isn't working for me.  i tried on Explorer, Chrome and FireFox and i got a server error everytime.  is that happening to anybody else?

Megaupload was taken down over a year ago. Kothund's sheets are already on the site though.

I feel like Ralph from Oracle of Ages when he tells Link that Rafton completed his waterproof rope before he died and it's in his tomb in the present.