[GBA] The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap - "Minish Woods" (Replacement) by Cashwarrior1

[Zeta]

Submission Information:
Series: The Legend of Zelda
Game: The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap
Console: Game Boy Advance
Title: Minish Woods
Instrumentation Solo Piano
Arranger: Cashwarrior1


Replacement Information:
Links to Existing Sheet: MUS | MIDI | PDF
Replacement Type: Challenge (new arranger)

[attachment deleted by admin]

[cashwarrior1]

[Static]

• m6 RH beats 1-2 should be beamed together. Finale is really weird when you try to add grace notes in the middle of a beam like that, so just press "/" on the selected note to beam it to the previous one.
• m8 LH beat 2 sounds like an Eb instead of F.
• m9 RH beat 2.5 should have a grace note like in m6.
• m10 LH beat 2.5 should be F instead of G.
• Maybe put slurs over the tied notes in m14-18 LH to match the accompaniment in m3-10.

Great sheet, nice to see a replacement for this one.

Edit: Also, Capcom and Flagship should be added as developers - Nintendo is just the publisher.

[cashwarrior1]

m10 LH beat 2.5 should be F instead of G.

I'm assuming you mean beat 2 LH. I hear that measure the exact same as measure 6.

Updated.

[Static]

I'm assuming you mean beat 2 LH. I hear that measure the exact same as measure 6.

Oops yeah that's correct.

For m8, I meant that beat 2 LH should be Eb. It goes G-F-Eb-G, not G-Eb-F-G. Everything else looks good

[Latios212]

Couple other small things aside from Static's above comment:

Maybe put slurs over the tied notes in m14-18 LH to match the accompaniment in m3-10.

I don't think that really makes much sense to slur a note to the same note that follows it here (m. 9-10 and 14-18).

- The high C in m. 14 sounds like it should be sustained the rest of the measure
- m. 14 is quite a stretch to hold down the low C while playing the upper C and En - don't think everyone will be able to do that. I think it'd be fine if the performer used pedal if needed so I don't think this must be written differently - just something to think about

[cashwarrior1]

- m. 14 is quite a stretch to hold down the low C while playing the upper C and En - don't think everyone will be able to do that. I think it'd be fine if the performer used pedal if needed so I don't think this must be written differently - just something to think about

Yeah. I know that I can play it, but I probably would use pedal there anyways, too.

Updated.

[Static]

I don't think that really makes much sense to slur a note to the same note that follows it here (m. 9-10 and 14-18).

This is getting into kinda nitpicky territory I realize, but there's nothing inherently wrong with slurring into the same note - if a note should be connected to the following one it should be notated that way. I know slurs can often be mistaken for ties, but in this case there's already a tie in all those spots. Perhaps just add a tenuto to those notes if you don't want a slur?

[Latios212]

This is getting into kinda nitpicky territory I realize, but there's nothing inherently wrong with slurring into the same note - if a note should be connected to the following one it should be notated that way. I know slurs can often be mistaken for ties, but in this case there's already a tie in all those spots. Perhaps just add a tenuto to those notes if you don't want a slur?

I can see why you might want that, but in my opinion slurs look extra weird here because the slur has a sloping contour when the notes aren't actually moving up and down.

Up to Cash though what you want to do with it? I like tenutos

[cashwarrior1]

I can see why you might want that, but in my opinion slurs look extra weird here because the slur has a sloping contour when the notes aren't actually moving up and down.

Up to Cash though what you want to do with it? I like tenutos

I will go with slurs, because looking at the sheet gives me slur vibes.

Updated.

[Latios212]

Alright, approved

[Static]

Cool, well I don't have anything else to add here. m8 looks good as well, so I'll accept

[Zeta]

This submission has been accepted by Static.

~Zeta, your friendly NSM-Bot