Recent posts

#51

Submission Archive / Re: [3DS] StreetPass Mii Plaza...

Last post by Zeta - July 21, 2024, 04:37:50 PM

This submission has been accepted by XiaoMigros.

~Zeta, your friendly NSM-Bot

[Accepted]

#52

Submission Archive / Re: [3DS] StreetPass Mii Plaza...

Last post by XiaoMigros - July 21, 2024, 04:37:39 PM

Thanks for making the changes! Accepted!

#53

Submission Archive / Re: [PC] Zoo Tycoon - "Title T...

Last post by XiaoMigros - July 21, 2024, 04:27:58 PM

That's a tricky spot to hear. I wasn't sure either - neither of them were sounding quite right to me, so I sought a third opinion from a friend and he heard it as Gn/Cn to A/C#. That sounds the most right to me so far... thoughts?

I'm hearing G# and B# to A and C#, but if you prefer you could write it as G#/D# to A/E to sound less muddy on the piano. Whichever option you prefer, but it's definitely G# for the low note!

[approval]

#54

Submissions / Re: [SNES] EarthBound - "Smile...

Last post by Latios212 - July 21, 2024, 04:09:44 PM

I shall leave my approval then ^^

[Approved]

#55

Submissions / Re: [WiiU] Mario Kart 8 - "Ice...

Last post by Latios212 - July 21, 2024, 04:01:32 PM

Cool cool, looks good to me! Approved

#56

Submissions / Re: [WiiU] Mario Kart 8 - "Ice...

Last post by XiaoMigros - July 21, 2024, 03:49:27 PM

- Thoughts about using an Ab in the chord of m. 20, similar to the measure prior?

I hear the string synth play Eb-Ab-C6 in m19 and C-Eb-G6 in m20, so I think it makes more sense as is. The rest has been changed though!

(It's cool how far this piece deviates from its home key of C)

Yes! I love how it takes you through so many chords, back to back to back

#57

Submissions / Re: [SNES] EarthBound - "Smile...

Last post by XiaoMigros - July 21, 2024, 03:43:02 PM

• In similar vein at m72 and 80, maybe you could hide the tie in RH 2nd layer between 2.5 and 3.0 (can have both layers' ties overlap visually).

I don't think I agree with this, I think it should be clear the notes are tied in each layer

The other changes have been made, thanks for reviewing

Just need to finalize my thoughts on some spots where it's a bit more arranged, but I don't want to be too driven by personal preferences.

If you have any thoughts by all means share them!

- The cross-staff beams in m. 44-47 could use a bit of adjusting, in particular having m. 46 first half angle up and maybe adding a bit more space between staves so the latter ones in m. 45/47 don't overlap the top staff?

I don't think there's enough vertical space available to move them outside the staff, but you're right about the angles being off so I adjusted those

- (I do think crediting the dads in the special thanks section is a bit excessive ahaha)

This was a joke and has been removed (forgot)

#58

Submission Archive / Re: [PC] Zoo Tycoon - "Title T...

Last post by Code_Name_Geek - July 21, 2024, 12:46:46 PM

- This piece is in A mixolydian, so it should be written in A major (three sharps) with G naturals in the melody.

Oh man, I totally meant to add a key signature but I must have forgotten. Done, thanks!

- For the left hand patterns in the even-numbered measures, I think it sounds a bit more chromatic - that is to say G#/D# instead of G/D - but I'm not too sure. What do you think?

That's a tricky spot to hear. I wasn't sure either - neither of them were sounding quite right to me, so I sought a third opinion from a friend and he heard it as Gn/Cn to A/C#. That sounds the most right to me so far... thoughts?

Doesn't surprise me for a 2001 PC game lol

The funny thing is that this would play during the entire lengthy installation process so the abrupt loop was really obvious... imagine listening to this for like half an hour while waiting for the game to install off of several discs haha.

Thanks for the feedback!

#59

Submissions / Re: [SNES] The Legend of the M...

Last post by Code_Name_Geek - July 21, 2024, 11:55:58 AM

This looks really good.

LH m1 b1-2 I'm hearing down an octave
LH m2 b4.5 I'm hearing as Bn not C#
LH m3 b1-2.0 I'm hearing down an octave (goes up to A#)
LH m3 b4.0 I'm hearing as F# (above current D#)

In measure 11 when the second melody goes to the LH, I think it would be better put in a second voice with opposing stems so it is clearer melody went.

Done, according to Kricketune54's adjustments.

• m1 and m3 beat RH 2.5 the D# should be a C#
• m12 LH beats 3 and 4 you could add an octave above to these notes

Did both of these as well.

Thanks to both of you for the feedback!

#60

Submissions / Re: [SNES] EarthBound - "Smile...

Last post by Latios212 - July 21, 2024, 11:26:00 AM

To confirm that this submission has not been forgotten about - Radiak, Xiao, and I have been making good progress going through this sheet at various points over the past few months. Should have stuff to show here sometime soon(ish)!

..aand ta-da! thanks both for the extensive time reviewing

I apologize for not posting in here earlier with any details, but yeah there was a lot of back and forth that would have unfortunately taken forever on the forums. I'm satisfied with this sheet in its current state and am almost ready to approve. A few small final things as I scan through the PDF:
- Overlapping noteheads need readjusting in m. 34 beat 4
- The cross-staff beams in m. 44-47 could use a bit of adjusting, in particular having m. 46 first half angle up and maybe adding a bit more space between staves so the latter ones in m. 45/47 don't overlap the top staff?
- I forget if Radiak had any final thoughts about the "I miss you" in m. 89, but I'm fine with it as written.
- Some notes/accidentals are a bit squished like in m. 49/51 (between beat 2.5-3), 81 (between beats 2.5-3) and 86 (the natural), mind checking the spacing is all up to date?
- (I do think crediting the dads in the special thanks section is a bit excessive ahaha)